Egg Shell Pots vs Clay Relic Jar: Which Outdoor Planter Wins
By OUTDOOR & lndoor planters for | Published: 2026-10-20
Category: Comparisons
Compare the Egg Shell Pots set and the Clay Relic Jar to find the best ceramic planter for your outdoor space, based on size, style, and value.
Quick answer
If you want a statement set that feels natural yet modern, the Egg Shell Pots are your pick; if you prefer a compact, rustic accent that works on a tabletop or shelf, the Clay Relic Jar is the smarter choice.
Size and placement: one planter vs a set of three
The Clay Relic Jar is a single ceramic planter measuring 6.5" x 6.5". That compact size makes it ideal for a small patio table, a balcony railing, or a windowsill where you want a subtle accent without taking up much floor space.
The Egg Shell Pots come as a set of three rounded, egg-shaped planters. You get more planting real estate and the flexibility to group them at different heights or spread them along a garden path. The set works better if you want to create a cohesive display or plant a variety of herbs and flowers.
Style and finish: rustic charm vs modern elegance
The Clay Relic Jar features an aged color assortment that gives it a Tuscan Sun Collection look. It feels like a piece of old-world pottery, perfect for Mediterranean or farmhouse garden themes. The aged finish means each jar may vary slightly, adding to its character.
The Egg Shell Pots are high-fired earthenware with a smooth hand-glazed finish. That smooth surface and rounded shape give them a more contemporary, almost sculptural appearance. They blend well with minimalist or modern outdoor settings where you want clean lines and a natural feel.
Trade-offs to consider
- Budget vs. quantity: The Clay Relic Jar costs $65.99 for one planter, while the Egg Shell Pots set is $299.97 for three. If you need a single accent, the jar is more affordable; if you want multiple planters, the set offers better value per piece. Calculate your cost per planter before deciding.
- Size vs. versatility: The Clay Relic Jar's 6.5" x 6.5" size fits tight spots but limits root space. The Egg Shell Pots, being larger and more numerous, suit bigger plants and more flexible arrangements. Consider the mature size of your plants before choosing.
- Style vs. uniqueness: The Clay Relic Jar's aged assortment means each piece may look slightly different, giving you a one-of-a-kind rustic charm. The Egg Shell Pots have a uniform, smooth finish for a consistent modern look. If you prefer a matching set, go with Egg Shell Pots; if you like character, choose the Clay Relic Jar.
Product facts at a glance
- CLAY RELIC JAR: The CLAY RELIC JAR is a ceramic planter sized 6.5" x 6.5" with an aged color assortment, part of the Tuscan Sun Collection. Its compact size and rustic finish make it a versatile accent for small spaces like tables, shelves, or narrow balconies.
CLAY RELIC JAR - Egg Shell Pots - Sets of 3 By Plantatorem: The Egg Shell Pots set of 3 are high-fired earthenware ceramic pieces with a smooth hand-glazed finish, suitable for indoor or outdoor placement. The set gives you multiple planters with a modern, natural look, ideal for creating a coordinated display or planting a variety of plants at once.
Egg Shell Pots - Sets of 3 By Plantatorem
Which planter fits you?
Best for
- Gardeners who want a modern, sculptural set of three to create a cohesive outdoor display
- Plant lovers who need multiple planters for a variety of plants or a balcony arrangement
Not for
- Those who need a single, budget-friendly accent for a small table or shelf
- Anyone who prefers a rustic, aged look over a smooth, contemporary finish
