Olive No Rim Jar vs Hand Thrown Planter: Which Outdoor Pot Fits
By OUTDOOR & lndoor planters for | Published: 2026-11-01
Category: Comparisons
Compare the Olive No Rim Jar and the Hand Thrown Planter set on shape, scale, and cost to decide which outdoor pot suits your patio or garden.
Quick answer
Choose the Olive No Rim Jar if you want one large, rimless statement piece for a patio or garden focal point. Choose the Hand Thrown Planter set of three if you need several smaller, handmade pots to group plants at a lower cost.
Rimless silhouette versus a set of three
The Olive No Rim Jar is a single rimless jar, so its top edge stays clean and uninterrupted. That shape draws attention to the plant rather than the pot's lip, which suits a patio corner or doorway where one container carries the scene.
The Hand Thrown Planter arrives as a set of three. Three pots let you build a grouped display, repeat a plant variety, or stage different heights without buying separate pieces. The trade-off is that each pot is smaller than a single statement jar, so the set reads as a collection rather than a focal point.
Handcrafted character and matching expectations
Both options are handcrafted earthenware, so expect slight variation between pieces. With the Olive No Rim Jar, that variation is part of one pot's character. With the Hand Thrown Planter set, the three pots may differ slightly from each other, which matters if you want a perfectly uniform row.
The Olive No Rim Jar belongs to the Tuscan sun earthen planters collection, a traditional ceramic look with a modern twist. The Hand Thrown Planter carries a Tuscan style as well, fired at 2200°F. Neither catalog entry lists frost resistance, drainage holes, or a precise capacity, so confirm those details before committing to an exposed winter site or a plant that needs sharp drainage.
Budget and scale trade-off
At catalog price, the Olive No Rim Jar is a single premium piece, while the Hand Thrown Planter set gives you three pots for less than a third of that price. The decision is less about which is better and more about whether your space needs one anchor or several supporting pots.
If you are choosing an outdoor planter for the first time, the set lowers the cost of experimenting with placement. If you already have a collection and want a centerpiece, the single rimless jar does a job the set cannot.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Visual weight: The Olive No Rim Jar gives you one large, rimless form that anchors a space; the Hand Thrown Planter set spreads visual weight across three smaller pots. Pick the jar for a focal point, the set for a grouped arrangement.
- Cost per pot: The set of three costs far less than the single Olive No Rim Jar at catalog price, but each pot is smaller. Compare price per pot, not just total price, if you need several containers.
- Uniformity: Hand-thrown pieces vary; the set may show differences among its three pots, while the single jar only has to satisfy on its own. If you need a matched row, inspect the set's variation before buying.
- Missing specifications: Neither listing states frost resistance, drainage, or exact capacity, so verify these with the store before choosing for exposed sites or drainage-sensitive plants. Ask about drainage and frost tolerance before finalizing either choice.
Product facts
- Olive No Rim Jar By Plantatorem: Single rimless jar from the Tuscan sun earthen planters collection, available in multiple sizes and colors. Size and color options let you scale one focal pot to a patio corner or entryway.
Olive No Rim Jar By Plantatorem - Hand Thrown Planter By Plantatorem: Handmade earthenware set of three, fired at 2200°F, available in multiple colors and sizes. Three coordinated pots make it easy to group plants without buying separate containers.
Hand Thrown Planter By Plantatorem
Which outdoor planter fits your space?
Best for
- A patio, doorway, or garden corner that needs one large rimless focal pot
- Gardeners and interior designers who want a single statement piece with size and color options
Not for
- Buyers who need several matching pots for a grouped display on a budget
- Anyone who needs confirmed frost resistance or drainage details before purchase
